1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.
  2. Hi Guest, welcome to the TES Community!

    Connect with like-minded education professionals and have your say on the issues that matter to you.

    Don't forget to look at the how to guide.

    Dismiss Notice

Where is an Architectural Graduate best placed in higher education - Art & Design or Design & Technology?

Discussion in 'Design and technology' started by arty_arch, Jun 11, 2012.

  1. Hi,

    I have both a BTEC National Diploma in Fine Art and a BA Hons in Architecture with RIBA Part 1 qualification.

    As someone thinking about training as a teacher (PGCE or GTTP) I am unsure where my skills are best placed. Would I be best placed as an Art & Design Teacher or as a Design Technology Teacher? Therefore I am keen to hear from anyone who works within an Art Department or a Design Technology Department at a secondary school or FE college.

    I left school back in 1998 and at that time Design Technology was namely focused on wood and metal work, but through some research I have seen that this subject has changed quite radically in some schools and now incorporate Graphic Design, 3D & Product Design, Textiles and Food Technology. Though at some schools I can see that architecture is quite heavily focused on as a subject within the Art & Design curriculum.

    Last summer I undertook 6 weeks teaching experience within a great art department at a high achieving coeducational school. The students were fantastic and though most of them were interested in Fine Art there were a few who were applying to study architecture. I felt I was able to engage with them all whether it was in painting, printmaking, sculpture, drawing, photography or architecture. I just want to be sure that I am not missing something having not experienced teaching within a Design & Technology Department.

    If you can offer any helpful advise or experience I look forward to hearing from you.
     
  2. I know a few schools that go down the modelling route when completing the final project in Year 13. To be honest, I don't feel I have the students that are capable of successfully meeting all the criteria set out in a design brief such as this. It is essential that those that do have close links with an architect who is able to guide them through the process.
    What I would recommend though is that you maybe download a copy of the A Level specification for Product Design and see for yourself what exactly is taught. You might be quite suprised at what is/isnt included.
    I have taught A Level Product Design using the WJEC exam board and I have found them extremely helpful if I've ever had a problem. There's no harm picking up the phone and asking a few questions. That's what they're for at the end of the day.
    This is the link to the A Level Spec that I follow: (DT1/2 is Year 12 and DT3/4 is Year 13)
    http://www.wjec.co.uk/index.php?subject=14&level=21&list=docs&docCatID=25
    Other exam boards include:
    AQA and Edexcel. It might be worth you downloading their specifications too just to familarise yourself with the structure of A Level Product Design across the board.
    Good luck, and drop us a reply if you get stuck or need any more help.
    Lee
     
  3. I did a degree in Interior Design and then went on to do PGCE in
    Secondary D&T. I have been teaching for 8 years and have come across lots
    of D&T Staff that teach Art but I haven't seen Art teachers doing D&T. Teacher
    training is an entry into a job but quite often schools will be looking for
    teachers that can teach or are willing to teach more than one subject. Quite
    often school's will have the D&T and Art departments in one Faculty with lots of cross over between the two.
     
  4. Thank you for your advise gemma - it's great to hear what you have experienced! At present I have some experience in textile design & dye, silversmithry, graphic design and materials (casting, plastics, wood, metal, form making). This experience combined with my BA in Architecture and my BTEC in Art & Design provides me with a number of cross over skills in both Design and Art. I may have managed to get myself 2 days observation within a DT department next week through a teacher friend. This should help me understand the differences between departments, although I am beginning to see that DT and Art & Design can often be taught combined in some schools or completely separately in others!
     

  5. <font size="2">I am in Yorkshire
    but I am presuming things are the same or similar.</font>

    <font size="2">When I applied to do a PGCE some universities wanted to offer a
    two year course and others offered a one year course, the main difference being
    the two year course allows you to build up your practical skills amongst other
    things. I choose a 1 year course because although I might not have demonstrated
    a great deal of practical skill during my interior design course I had other
    skills that I had build up though courses I had worked on and my A-level work.</font>

    <font size="2">In terms of practical craft skills they will be looking for your
    ability to manufacture to some degree. What area of D&T do you want to specialise
    in? This will determine some of the skills needed.</font>

    <font size="2">You may have some of the skills needed already. As part of your
    interior design course did you do any modeling for example? This would be
    related, I created a number of models using different techniques and also
    combining cad/cam which I was able to show at interview.</font>

    <font size="2">If you want you can email me directly if I can be of any more help
    - </font>g.postings@challenge.ngfl.ac.uk

     

Share This Page