At no point did I use the word "we" to exclude any minority! Quite. And, as per my previous posts, if we are going to provide education in one minority's tongue, why not all of them? The answer to this is clear: because it is not economically viable. I think you'll find that the majority of Scottish taxpayers don't give Gaelic education a second thought. How dreadful, you think. Maybe you're right. Maybe I am a cultural ******. So be it.