I mean I'm picky. As I say; I make comments such as "downward inflection in voice" or "lacks fluidity in movement; particularly in scene X". We've not been instructed to say anything to be honest. At the standardisation meeting, I was surprised to see that I was, at times, a little generous in my marking (we practiced by watching some examples on video and marked them before being told the marks awarded). As I've said before, the marks that I initially gave may NOT be the marks that appear as the final mark as the work is re-marked before final marks are issued. I mark what I see but I don't think I'm over generous - in that sense fair. And, I HAVE seen lots of brilliant stuff......as I am sure I will again next year. None of that probably makes sense but I know what I mean, in my head anyway!!!